2002 Senate Bill 1436 ↩

House Roll Call 1249: The amendment was not adopted

To limit to 200 each the number of beds the Detroit Medical Center, the Henry Ford Health System, and the Providence/St. Johns Health System will be allowed to transfer from their Detroit to their Oakland County hospitals.

44 Yeas / 60 Nays

Republican (3 Yeas / 54 Nays)

Bishop (R-45) Godchaux (R-40) Rocca (R-30)	Allen (R-104) Birkholz (R-88) Bisbee (R-64) Bradstreet (R-105) Brown (R-59) Cassis (R-38) Caul (R-99) DeRossett (R-55) DeVuyst (R-93) DeWeese (R-67) Drolet (R-33) Ehardt (R-83) George (R-61) Gilbert (R-82) Gosselin (R-42) Hager (R-81) Hart (R-73) Howell (R-94) Hummel (R-86) Jansen (R-72) Jelinek (R-78) Johnson (R-102) Johnson (R-46) Julian (R-85) Koetje (R-74) Kooiman (R-75) Kowall (R-44) Kuipers (R-90) LaSata (R-79) Mead (R-101) Meyer (R-84) Middaugh (R-80) Mortimer (R-65) Newell (R-87) Palmer (R-32) Pappageorge (R-41) Patterson (R-21) Pumford (R-100) Raczkowski (R-37) Richardville (R-56) Richner (R-1) Scranton (R-66) Shackleton (R-107) Shulman (R-39) Stamas (R-98) Stewart (R-20) Tabor (R-71) Toy (R-19) Van Woerkom (R-91) Vander Veen (R-89) Vander Roest (R-63) Vear (R-58) Voorhees (R-77) Woronchak (R-15)

Republican (3 Yeas / 54 Nays)

Bishop (R-45)
Godchaux (R-40)
Rocca (R-30)

Allen (R-104)
Birkholz (R-88)
Bisbee (R-64)
Bradstreet (R-105)
Brown (R-59)
Cassis (R-38)
Caul (R-99)
DeRossett (R-55)
DeVuyst (R-93)
DeWeese (R-67)
Drolet (R-33)
Ehardt (R-83)
George (R-61)
Gilbert (R-82)
Gosselin (R-42)
Hager (R-81)
Hart (R-73)
Howell (R-94)
Hummel (R-86)
Jansen (R-72)
Jelinek (R-78)
Johnson (R-102)
Johnson (R-46)
Julian (R-85)
Koetje (R-74)
Kooiman (R-75)
Kowall (R-44)
Kuipers (R-90)
LaSata (R-79)
Mead (R-101)
Meyer (R-84)
Middaugh (R-80)
Mortimer (R-65)
Newell (R-87)
Palmer (R-32)
Pappageorge (R-41)
Patterson (R-21)
Pumford (R-100)
Raczkowski (R-37)
Richardville (R-56)
Richner (R-1)
Scranton (R-66)
Shackleton (R-107)
Shulman (R-39)
Stamas (R-98)
Stewart (R-20)
Tabor (R-71)
Toy (R-19)
Van Woerkom (R-91)
Vander Veen (R-89)
Vander Roest (R-63)
Vear (R-58)
Voorhees (R-77)
Woronchak (R-15)

Democrat (41 Yeas / 6 Nays)

Adamini (D-109) Anderson (D-18) Basham (D-22) Bernero (D-68) Bogardus (D-47) Bovin (D-108) Brown (D-110) Callahan (D-26) Clark-Coleman (D-11) Daniels (D-5) Dennis (D-92) Durhal (D-9) Frank (D-96) Gieleghem (D-31) Hansen (D-52) Hardman (D-3) Jacobs (D-35) Jamnick (D-54) Kolb (D-53) Lipsey (D-60) Lockwood (D-51) McConico (D-6) Minore (D-49) Murphy (D-69) Neumann (D-106) Pestka (D-76) Phillips (D-43) Quarles (D-36) Rison (D-48) Rivet (D-97) Schauer (D-62) Sheltrown (D-103) Spade (D-57) Stallworth (D-12) Switalski (D-27) Waters (D-4) Whitmer (D-70) Williams (D-95) Wojno (D-28) Woodward (D-34) Zelenko (D-50)	Brown (D-16) Garza (D-8) Lemmons III (D-2) Mans (D-23) O'Neil (D-24) Schermesser (D-25)

Democrat (41 Yeas / 6 Nays)

Adamini (D-109)
Anderson (D-18)
Basham (D-22)
Bernero (D-68)
Bogardus (D-47)
Bovin (D-108)
Brown (D-110)
Callahan (D-26)
Clark-Coleman (D-11)
Daniels (D-5)
Dennis (D-92)
Durhal (D-9)
Frank (D-96)
Gieleghem (D-31)
Hansen (D-52)
Hardman (D-3)
Jacobs (D-35)
Jamnick (D-54)
Kolb (D-53)
Lipsey (D-60)
Lockwood (D-51)
McConico (D-6)
Minore (D-49)
Murphy (D-69)
Neumann (D-106)
Pestka (D-76)
Phillips (D-43)
Quarles (D-36)
Rison (D-48)
Rivet (D-97)
Schauer (D-62)
Sheltrown (D-103)
Spade (D-57)
Stallworth (D-12)
Switalski (D-27)
Waters (D-4)
Whitmer (D-70)
Williams (D-95)
Wojno (D-28)
Woodward (D-34)
Zelenko (D-50)

Brown (D-16)
Garza (D-8)
Lemmons III (D-2)
Mans (D-23)
O'Neil (D-24)
Schermesser (D-25)

Excused or Not Voting (6)

Faunce (R-29) Reeves (D-13) Clarke (D-7) Hale (D-14) Plakas (D-17) Thomas (D-10)