Senate Roll Call 18 - Michigan Votes

Legislation watch

2011 House Bill 5192: Revise Detroit police and fire pension board selection (Senate Roll Call 18)

Passed 35 to 2 in the Senate on January 25, 2012, to clarify that if the Detroit fire and police pension board member who is supposed to represent retirees is selected according to a method specified in the city charter, then deciding who to select would be a prohibited subject of collective bargaining with government employee unions, and any union agreement specifying a different person or method would be null and void. See also House Bill 4135, now Public Act 25 of 2011, which dealt with the same issue.
View All of House Bill 5192: History, Amendments & Comments

The vote was 35 in favor, 2 against, and 1 not voting.
(Senate Roll Call 18)

Comment on this vote View others' comments Add to scorecard

Line

Vote

In Favor

Against

Not Voting

Undecided

Democrat

	75%
	16%
	8%

12 total votes

Republican

	100%
	0%
	0%

26 total votes

Line

Revise Detroit police and fire pension board selection

IN FAVOR

SENATE DEMOCRATS

Anderson (D)	Bieda (D)	Gleason (D)	Gregory (D)	Hopgood (D)
Hunter (D)	Johnson (D)	Smith (D)	Young (D)

SENATE REPUBLICANS

Booher (R)	Brandenburg (R)	Casperson (R)	Caswell (R)	Colbeck (R)
Emmons (R)	Green (R)	Hansen (R)	Hildenbrand (R)	Hune (R)
Jansen (R)	Jones (R)	Kahn (R)	Kowall (R)	Marleau (R)
Meekhof (R)	Moolenaar (R)	Nofs (R)	Pappageorge (R)	Pavlov (R)
Proos (R)	Richardville (R)	Robertson (R)	Rocca (R)	Schuitmaker (R)
Walker (R)

AGAINST

SENATE DEMOCRATS

Warren (D)

Whitmer (D)

SENATE REPUBLICANS
none

SENATE LEGISLATORS WHO DID NOT VOTE

Hood (D)

SENATE LEGISLATORS ALL VOTES

Y Anderson (D)	Y Bieda (D)	Y Booher (R)	Y Brandenburg (R)	Y Casperson (R)
Y Caswell (R)	Y Colbeck (R)	Y Emmons (R)	Y Gleason (D)	Y Green (R)
Y Gregory (D)	Y Hansen (R)	Y Hildenbrand (R)	- Hood (D)	Y Hopgood (D)
Y Hune (R)	Y Hunter (D)	Y Jansen (R)	Y Johnson (D)	Y Jones (R)
Y Kahn (R)	Y Kowall (R)	Y Marleau (R)	Y Meekhof (R)	Y Moolenaar (R)
Y Nofs (R)	Y Pappageorge (R)	Y Pavlov (R)	Y Proos (R)	Y Richardville (R)
Y Robertson (R)	Y Rocca (R)	Y Schuitmaker (R)	Y Smith (D)	Y Walker (R)
n Warren (D)	n Whitmer (D)	Y Young (D)