Legislation watch
Mackinac Center for Public Policy
Capitol Building

2010 Senate Bill 1163: Appropriations: 2010-2011 school aid budget (Senate Roll Call 157)
facebook  twitter 

Amendment offered by Sen. Michael Switalski (D) on March 24, 2010, to tie-bar the bill to Senate Bill 888, meaning this bill cannot become law unless that one does also. SB 888 would require all elections in the state to be held on either the August or November election days. The amendment failed 10 to 27 in the Senate on March 24, 2010.
View All of Senate Bill 1163: History, Amendments & Comments 

The vote was 10 in favor, 27 against, and 1 not voting.
(Senate Roll Call 157)

Print-friendly version

 Comment on this vote   View others' comments   Add to scorecard 

Line

Vote
In Favor In Favor
Against Against
Not Voting Not Voting
 Undecided
Republican
1000%
95595%
4964%
22 total votes
Democrat
623862%
376337%
1000%
16 total votes

What do you think? In Favor Against Undecided (log on required)

Line

The amendment

IN FAVOR

SENATE DEMOCRATS

Basham (D)Clark-Coleman (D)Clarke (D)Gleason (D)Hunter (D)
Olshove (D)Scott (D)Switalski (D)Thomas (D)Whitmer (D)

SENATE REPUBLICANS
none


AGAINST

SENATE DEMOCRATS

Anderson (D)Barcia (D)Brater (D)Cherry (D)Jacobs (D)
Prusi (D)    

SENATE REPUBLICANS

Allen (R)Birkholz (R)Bishop (R)Brown (R)Cassis (R)
Cropsey (R)George (R)Gilbert (R)Hardiman (R)Jansen (R)
Jelinek (R)Kahn (R)Kuipers (R)McManus (R)Nofs (R)
Pappageorge (R)Patterson (R)Richardville (R)Sanborn (R)Stamas (R)
Van Woerkom (R)    


SENATE LEGISLATORS WHO DID NOT VOTE

Garcia (R)



SENATE LEGISLATORS ALL VOTES

  n  Allen (R)  n  Anderson (D)  n  Barcia (D)Y    Basham (D)  n  Birkholz (R)
  n  Bishop (R)  n  Brater (D)  n  Brown (R)  n  Cassis (R)  n  Cherry (D)
Y    Clark-Coleman (D)Y    Clarke (D)  n  Cropsey (R)  -  Garcia (R)  n  George (R)
  n  Gilbert (R)Y    Gleason (D)  n  Hardiman (R)Y    Hunter (D)  n  Jacobs (D)
  n  Jansen (R)  n  Jelinek (R)  n  Kahn (R)  n  Kuipers (R)  n  McManus (R)
  n  Nofs (R)Y    Olshove (D)  n  Pappageorge (R)  n  Patterson (R)  n  Prusi (D)
  n  Richardville (R)  n  Sanborn (R)Y    Scott (D)  n  Stamas (R)Y    Switalski (D)
Y    Thomas (D)  n  Van Woerkom (R)Y    Whitmer (D)  

Senate Roll Call 157 on The amendment

Line

Comments

Re: 2010 Senate Bill 1163 (Appropriations: 2010-2011 school aid budget )  by Admin003 on March 24, 2010 

 6



Senator Switalski's second statement is as follows:


It is true, imitation is the sincerest form of flattery. Once again, I have been borrowing the brilliant ideas from my


colleagues from across the aisle and offering them as my own in these amendments, but I give them full credit.


These are very good ideas. This amendment tie-bars a substitute to a Birkholz bill that would restrict administrative


costs to no more than 28 percent. This is part of the Republican package of reforms. I think it is a very legitimate


reform. We have to drive resources into the classroom, and this is a way to do that. I hope that all members will


support this. It is the type of thing that we should be doing when we are looking at reforms.


Senator Switalski's third statement is as follows:


This one is actually one of my own bills. I have to take credit for this one. It is a tie-bar to an election


consolidation bill that would restrict elections to August and November. Let me add that my two worthy colleagues-


-great minds think alike--Senators McManus and Brown have offered similar legislation to consolidate elections. I


commend them for these ideas. We all are thinking along the same lines, that schools are wasting resources and


government is wasting resources by holding duplicative, low-turnout elections. We should consolidate them to


August and November. This tie-bar would do that. I hope members will vote for more efficient government and


support my amendment.




Re: 2010 Senate Bill 1163 (Appropriations: 2010-2011 school aid budget )  by Admin003 on March 24, 2010 

 5



Senator Switalski asked and was granted unanimous consent to make statements and moved that the statements be


printed in the Journal.


The motion prevailed.


Senator Switalski's first statement is as follows:


This amendment will tie-bar the budget bill to a substitute to a brilliant Senator Patterson bill that places a cap on


superintendent wages. We all know how shy and retiring Senator Patterson is, and he doesn't want to get up and


speak about his own bill, but I think it is so good and I like it so much that I want to tie-bar this budget bill to it. We


have to do a lot of reforms, and we've got to make some cuts. I think this is a very reasonable thing to do. The cuts


should be felt all the way through education. I hope members will support this tie-bar that will require a cap on


superintendent wages.




Re: 2010 Senate Bill 1163 (Appropriations: 2010-2011 school aid budget )  by Admin003 on March 24, 2010 

 4




View pre-2013 Comments.
Your new comments should be made in the box below.