Legislation watch
Mackinac Center for Public Policy
Capitol Building

2007 House Bill 4896: Establish adoptee birth parent identification process (House Roll Call 659)
facebook  twitter 

Passed 99 to 8 in the House on June 27, 2008.
View All of House Bill 4896: History, Amendments & Comments 

The vote was 99 in favor, 8 against, and 3 not voting.
(House Roll Call 659 at House Journal 65)

Print-friendly version

 Comment on this vote   View others' comments   Add to scorecard 

Line

Vote
In Favor In Favor
Against Against
Not Voting Not Voting
 Undecided
Democrat
98298%
1000%
1991%
58 total votes
Republican
802080%
158515%
3973%
52 total votes
Voters
100100%
1000%
1000%
1 total vote

What do you think? In Favor Against Undecided (log on required)

Line

Establish adoptee birth parent identification process

IN FAVOR

HOUSE DEMOCRATS

Accavitti (D)Angerer (D)Bauer (D)Bennett (D)Bieda (D)
Brown (D)Byrnes (D)Byrum (D)Cheeks (D)Clack (D)
Clemente (D)Condino (D)Constan (D)Corriveau (D)Coulouris (D)
Cushingberry (D)Dean (D)Dillon (D)Donigan (D)Ebli (D)
Espinoza (D)Farrah (D)Gillard (D)Gonzales (D)Griffin (D)
Hammel (D)Hammon (D)Hood (D)Hopgood (D)Jackson (D)
Johnson (D)Jones, Robert (D)Lahti (D)Law, Kathleen (D)LeBlanc (D)
Leland (D)Lindberg (D)Mayes (D)McDowell (D)Meadows (D)
Meisner (D)Melton (D)Miller (D)Polidori (D)Sak (D)
Scott (D)Sheltrown (D)Simpson (D)Smith, Alma (D)Smith, Virgil (D)
Spade (D)Tobocman (D)Vagnozzi (D)Valentine (D)Warren (D)
Wojno (D)Young (D)   

HOUSE REPUBLICANS

Acciavatti (R)Amos (R)Ball (R)Booher (R)Calley (R)
Casperson (R)DeRoche (R)Elsenheimer (R)Emmons (R)Gaffney (R)
Green (R)Hansen (R)Hildenbrand (R)Hoogendyk (R)Horn (R)
Huizenga (R)Hune (R)Jones, Rick (R)Knollenberg (R)LaJoy (R)
Law, David (R)Marleau (R)Meekhof (R)Meltzer (R)Moolenaar (R)
Moss (R)Nitz (R)Opsommer (R)Palsrok (R)Pastor (R)
Pavlov (R)Pearce (R)Proos (R)Rocca (R)Schuitmaker (R)
Shaffer (R)Sheen (R)Stahl (R)Stakoe (R)Walker (R)
Ward (R)Wenke (R)   


AGAINST

HOUSE DEMOCRATS
none

HOUSE REPUBLICANS

Agema (R)Brandenburg (R)Caswell (R)Caul (R)Moore (R)
Nofs (R)Palmer (R)Steil (R)  


HOUSE LEGISLATORS WHO DID NOT VOTE

Garfield (R)Lemmons (D)Robertson (R)



HOUSE LEGISLATORS ALL VOTES

Y    Accavitti (D)Y    Acciavatti (R)  n  Agema (R)Y    Amos (R)Y    Angerer (D)
Y    Ball (R)Y    Bauer (D)Y    Bennett (D)Y    Bieda (D)Y    Booher (R)
  n  Brandenburg (R)Y    Brown (D)Y    Byrnes (D)Y    Byrum (D)Y    Calley (R)
Y    Casperson (R)  n  Caswell (R)  n  Caul (R)Y    Cheeks (D)Y    Clack (D)
Y    Clemente (D)Y    Condino (D)Y    Constan (D)Y    Corriveau (D)Y    Coulouris (D)
Y    Cushingberry (D)Y    Dean (D)Y    DeRoche (R)Y    Dillon (D)Y    Donigan (D)
Y    Ebli (D)Y    Elsenheimer (R)Y    Emmons (R)Y    Espinoza (D)Y    Farrah (D)
Y    Gaffney (R)  -  Garfield (R)Y    Gillard (D)Y    Gonzales (D)Y    Green (R)
Y    Griffin (D)Y    Hammel (D)Y    Hammon (D)Y    Hansen (R)Y    Hildenbrand (R)
Y    Hood (D)Y    Hoogendyk (R)Y    Hopgood (D)Y    Horn (R)Y    Huizenga (R)
Y    Hune (R)Y    Jackson (D)Y    Johnson (D)Y    Jones, Rick (R)Y    Jones, Robert (D)
Y    Knollenberg (R)Y    Lahti (D)Y    LaJoy (R)Y    Law, David (R)Y    Law, Kathleen (D)
Y    LeBlanc (D)Y    Leland (D)  -  Lemmons (D)Y    Lindberg (D)Y    Marleau (R)
Y    Mayes (D)Y    McDowell (D)Y    Meadows (D)Y    Meekhof (R)Y    Meisner (D)
Y    Melton (D)Y    Meltzer (R)Y    Miller (D)Y    Moolenaar (R)  n  Moore (R)
Y    Moss (R)Y    Nitz (R)  n  Nofs (R)Y    Opsommer (R)  n  Palmer (R)
Y    Palsrok (R)Y    Pastor (R)Y    Pavlov (R)Y    Pearce (R)Y    Polidori (D)
Y    Proos (R)  -  Robertson (R)Y    Rocca (R)Y    Sak (D)Y    Schuitmaker (R)
Y    Scott (D)Y    Shaffer (R)Y    Sheen (R)Y    Sheltrown (D)Y    Simpson (D)
Y    Smith, Alma (D)Y    Smith, Virgil (D)Y    Spade (D)Y    Stahl (R)Y    Stakoe (R)
  n  Steil (R)Y    Tobocman (D)Y    Vagnozzi (D)Y    Valentine (D)Y    Walker (R)
Y    Ward (R)Y    Warren (D)Y    Wenke (R)Y    Wojno (D)Y    Young (D)

House Roll Call 659 on 2007 House Bill 4896

Line

Comments

1) Re: 2007 House Bill 4896 (Establish adoptee birth parent identification process )  by jimm on April 28, 2010 

 Alaska and Kansas, two states which have never sealed birth certificates from adoptees, and Oregon which made birth certificates available to adult adoptees ten years ago, have LOWER abortion rates and HIGHER adoption rates than ANY state with sealed birth certificates. Those who think allowing adult adoptees to have their birth certificates will result in an increase in abortions are absolutely WRONG.


Senator Jansen does not support equality for all adult citizens and will never support legislation such as HB4896.


Line

2) Re: Basic Human Rights Huh?  by khmior on May 11, 2009 

I'm thrilled at the prospect of being able to obtain a copy of my original birth certificate, trully a dream come. I appreciate all the comments and frustrations of the other adoptees.  I too have looked in to the mirror and wished I knew someone who looked like me and was not pleasanty surprised to find a registration card instead of a birth certificate.  While it's too late to meet my birth parents as I'm nearly 60, I would like to have their names. Hurray for the forward looking legislators!  Kathleen, born Suzanne Marie 4/23/50 Detroit.


Line

3) Another side  by Anonymous Citizen on October 22, 2008 
As the wife of an adoptee, I can assure you there's more to wanting an original birth certificate than just wanting to meet birth parents.

My husband is adopted. We were fortunate to conceive our first child quickly. However we went through 18 months of trying to conceive our second child. When we were finally referred to a specialist, going through a medical history we had no idea about was very difficult for my husband. He shut down for days afterward. He felt that he wasn't contributing enough to the cause of getting pregnant. When I finally did become pregnant, we were referred for high-risk as I'm 35. That meant genetic counseling. Again, my husband shut down because he had no answers to give.

We are so grateful for Rep. Wojno for sponsoring this legislation and hope the Senate approves it quickly.

It is not only for our benefit that we seek answers, but for our children. Our first child is developmentally delayed and while he has had some genetic testing, it only provides a fraction of the puzzle.

All children deserve to know their history, whether it's their ethnic background or what's in their genetic make-up.

Can you imagine sitting in a doctor's office and answering "I don't know" to a list of 50+ questions just because you're adopted and have no access to your file?

I don't have to imagine it, I've been watching it happen for five years and it's just as disheartening to watch as it is to go through it.

Line

View pre-2013 Comments.
Your new comments should be made in the box below.