Legislation watch
Mackinac Center for Public Policy
Capitol Building

2007 House Bill 5105 (Repeal Detroit income tax reduction law ) (House Roll Call 448)

Passed in the House (73 to 35) on October 3, 2007, to repeal a law that requires Detroit to gradually reduce its city income tax to 2.0 percent for residents and 1.0 percent for non-residents who work in the city. The law lets Detroit postpone annual one-tenth of a percent reductions if certain conditions apply, which has been the case since 2004, but will not apply this year. Under the bill Detroit may levy an income tax allowed of 3 percent rax on residents, and 1.5 percent on nonresidents who work there. [History, Amendments & Comments]

The vote was 73 in favor, 35 opposed, and 2 not voting
(House Roll Call 448 at House Journal 104)

Print-friendly version

[Comment on this vote | View others' comments]

Line

Vote
Support Support
Oppose Oppose
Not Voting Not Voting
 Undecided
Legislators (Democrat)
861486%
138713%
1000%
58 total votes
Legislators (Republican)
445644%
514951%
3973%
52 total votes
Voters
1000%
100100%
1000%
2 total votes

What do you think? Support Oppose Undecided (logon required)

Line

The following legislators supported 2007 House Bill 5105 (Repeal Detroit income tax reduction law ):

Accavitti (D) Angerer (D) Ball (R) Bauer (D) Bennett (D) Bieda (D)
Booher (R) Byrnes (D) Calley (R) Casperson (R) Caul (R) Cheeks (D)
Clack (D) Clemente (D) Condino (D) Constan (D) Coulouris (D) Cushingberry (D)
Dean (D) Dillon (D) Donigan (D) Elsenheimer (R) Emmons (R) Espinoza (D)
Farrah (D) Gaffney (R) Gillard (D) Gonzales (D) Green (R) Griffin (D)
Hammel (D) Hansen (R) Hildenbrand (R) Hood (D) Hopgood (D) Huizenga (R)
Jackson (D) Johnson (D) Jones, Rick (R) Jones, Robert (D) Lahti (D) Law, Kathleen (D)
LeBlanc (D) Leland (D) Lemmons (D) Lindberg (D) Mayes (D) McDowell (D)
Meadows (D) Meekhof (R) Meisner (D) Melton (D) Miller (D) Nitz (R)
Nofs (R) Pastor (R) Pearce (R) Polidori (D) Proos (R) Sak (D)
Schuitmaker (R) Scott (D) Shaffer (R) Sheltrown (D) Smith, Alma (D) Smith, Virgil (D)
Stakoe (R) Tobocman (D) Vagnozzi (D) Warren (D) Wenke (R) Wojno (D)
Young (D)      

The following legislators opposed 2007 House Bill 5105 (Repeal Detroit income tax reduction law ):

Acciavatti (R) Agema (R) Amos (R) Brandenburg (R) Brown (D) Byrum (D)
Caswell (R) Corriveau (D) DeRoche (R) Ebli (D) Hammon (D) Horn (R)
Hune (R) Knollenberg (R) LaJoy (R) Law, David (R) Marleau (R) Meltzer (R)
Moolenaar (R) Moore (R) Moss (R) Opsommer (R) Palmer (R) Palsrok (R)
Pavlov (R) Robertson (R) Rocca (R) Sheen (R) Simpson (D) Spade (D)
Stahl (R) Steil (R) Valentine (D) Walker (R) Ward (R)  

The following legislators did not vote on 2007 House Bill 5105 (Repeal Detroit income tax reduction law ):

Garfield (R) Hoogendyk (R)

Line

Most Recent Comments

1) Excellent Idea [by Anonymous Citizen on March 14, 2008]
make it 25% and then we can start over after the dust has settled.
Reply

Line

2) Thanks, Detroit [by Anonymous Citizen on March 14, 2008]
Just because I get a job in your city limits doesn't mean you should have any right to any money I make. You're just going to throw it away on the endless roadwork that makes the roads unusable.
Reply

Line

3) why is a city imposing [by Anonymous Citizen on September 7, 2007]
an income tax in the first place?

is this CONSTITUTIONAL?

is this LEGAL?

why don't ALL michigan cities impose an income tax? probably because detroit got a VARIANCE FROM THE LAW THAT PREVENTS OTHER CITIES FROM IMPOSING AN ILLEGAL INCOME TAX.

why does our state legislature bend over backwards to allow government entities to take the taxpayer's money?


Reply

Line


View Full Conversation