Passed 59 to 46 in the House on July 25, 2007.
View All of House Bill 4533: History, Amendments & Comments
The vote was 59 in favor, 46 against, and 5 not voting.
(House Roll Call 267 at House Journal 73)
Allow teachers union to bargain for privatization ban
|Accavitti (D)||Angerer (D)||Bauer (D)||Bennett (D)||Bieda (D)|
|Brown (D)||Byrnes (D)||Byrum (D)||Cheeks (D)||Clack (D)|
|Clemente (D)||Condino (D)||Constan (D)||Corriveau (D)||Coulouris (D)|
|Cushingberry (D)||Dean (D)||Donigan (D)||Ebli (D)||Espinoza (D)|
|Farrah (D)||Gillard (D)||Gonzales (D)||Griffin (D)||Hammel (D)|
|Hammon (D)||Hood (D)||Jackson (D)||Johnson (D)||Jones, Robert (D)|
|Lahti (D)||Law, Kathleen (D)||LeBlanc (D)||Leland (D)||Lemmons (D)|
|Lindberg (D)||Mayes (D)||McDowell (D)||Meadows (D)||Meisner (D)|
|Melton (D)||Miller (D)||Polidori (D)||Sak (D)||Scott (D)|
|Sheltrown (D)||Simpson (D)||Smith, Alma (D)||Smith, Virgil (D)||Spade (D)|
|Tobocman (D)||Vagnozzi (D)||Valentine (D)||Warren (D)||Wojno (D)|
|Casperson (R)||Gaffney (R)||Rocca (R)|
|Acciavatti (R)||Agema (R)||Amos (R)||Ball (R)||Booher (R)|
|Brandenburg (R)||Calley (R)||Caswell (R)||Caul (R)||Elsenheimer (R)|
|Garfield (R)||Green (R)||Hansen (R)||Hildenbrand (R)||Hoogendyk (R)|
|Horn (R)||Huizenga (R)||Hune (R)||Jones, Rick (R)||Knollenberg (R)|
|LaJoy (R)||Law, David (R)||Marleau (R)||Meekhof (R)||Meltzer (R)|
|Moolenaar (R)||Moore (R)||Moss (R)||Nitz (R)||Nofs (R)|
|Opsommer (R)||Palmer (R)||Palsrok (R)||Pastor (R)||Pavlov (R)|
|Pearce (R)||Proos (R)||Robertson (R)||Schuitmaker (R)||Shaffer (R)|
|Stahl (R)||Stakoe (R)||Steil (R)||Walker (R)||Ward (R)|
HOUSE LEGISLATORS WHO DID NOT VOTE
|DeRoche (R)||Dillon (D)||Emmons (R)||Hopgood (D)||Sheen (R)|
HOUSE LEGISLATORS ALL VOTES
|Y Accavitti (D)||n Acciavatti (R)||n Agema (R)||n Amos (R)||Y Angerer (D)|
|n Ball (R)||Y Bauer (D)||Y Bennett (D)||Y Bieda (D)||n Booher (R)|
|n Brandenburg (R)||Y Brown (D)||Y Byrnes (D)||Y Byrum (D)||n Calley (R)|
|Y Casperson (R)||n Caswell (R)||n Caul (R)||Y Cheeks (D)||Y Clack (D)|
|Y Clemente (D)||Y Condino (D)||Y Constan (D)||Y Corriveau (D)||Y Coulouris (D)|
|Y Cushingberry (D)||Y Dean (D)||- DeRoche (R)||- Dillon (D)||Y Donigan (D)|
|Y Ebli (D)||n Elsenheimer (R)||- Emmons (R)||Y Espinoza (D)||Y Farrah (D)|
|Y Gaffney (R)||n Garfield (R)||Y Gillard (D)||Y Gonzales (D)||n Green (R)|
|Y Griffin (D)||Y Hammel (D)||Y Hammon (D)||n Hansen (R)||n Hildenbrand (R)|
|Y Hood (D)||n Hoogendyk (R)||- Hopgood (D)||n Horn (R)||n Huizenga (R)|
|n Hune (R)||Y Jackson (D)||Y Johnson (D)||n Jones, Rick (R)||Y Jones, Robert (D)|
|n Knollenberg (R)||Y Lahti (D)||n LaJoy (R)||n Law, David (R)||Y Law, Kathleen (D)|
|Y LeBlanc (D)||Y Leland (D)||Y Lemmons (D)||Y Lindberg (D)||n Marleau (R)|
|Y Mayes (D)||Y McDowell (D)||Y Meadows (D)||n Meekhof (R)||Y Meisner (D)|
|Y Melton (D)||n Meltzer (R)||Y Miller (D)||n Moolenaar (R)||n Moore (R)|
|n Moss (R)||n Nitz (R)||n Nofs (R)||n Opsommer (R)||n Palmer (R)|
|n Palsrok (R)||n Pastor (R)||n Pavlov (R)||n Pearce (R)||Y Polidori (D)|
|n Proos (R)||n Robertson (R)||Y Rocca (R)||Y Sak (D)||n Schuitmaker (R)|
|Y Scott (D)||n Shaffer (R)||- Sheen (R)||Y Sheltrown (D)||Y Simpson (D)|
|Y Smith, Alma (D)||Y Smith, Virgil (D)||Y Spade (D)||n Stahl (R)||n Stakoe (R)|
|n Steil (R)||Y Tobocman (D)||Y Vagnozzi (D)||Y Valentine (D)||n Walker (R)|
|n Ward (R)||Y Warren (D)||n Wenke (R)||Y Wojno (D)||Y Young (D)|
House Roll Call 267 on 2007 House Bill 4533
allowing teachers to bargain against privatization is taking away their CHOICE. as in you are not allowing teachers to bargain FOR privatization.
who knows, you might just find enough teachers to whom merit is more important than union dues that might just vote FOR privatization.
but this bill takes away that FREEDOM OF CHOICE.
2) Re: When is it too much? by crazycajun on January 29, 2009
by the way, blue...
you list chicago as your 'other home'.
pity about your democrat governor getting impeached by a unanimous vote of the illinois senate.
perhaps this will give michiganders the needed incentive to bring impeachment against granholm for really screwing up this state.
3) Re: When is it too much? by crazycajun on January 29, 2009
teachers pay is paid out of state funds, allocated to local and county boards.
i'd say that the union is a BIG part of the problem, as it perpetuates mediocre education by maintaining mediocre teachers. it also seeks advancement not based on merit, but on union membership.
they also donate money to political causes not associated with education, whether the members agree or not.
to some this is graft, corruption, and theft.
View pre-2013 Comments.