Legislation watch
Mackinac Center for Public Policy
Capitol Building

2007 House Bill 4375 (Revise commercial rental property assessment occupancy formula ) (House Roll Call 95)

Substitute offered by Rep. Fulton Sheen (R) on April 17, 2007, to replace the previous version of the bill with one that eliminate the retroactive nature of the bill, which would require property owners to pay higher taxes in the future to compensate governments for past tax savings under the WPW ruling. The substitute failed in the House (51 to 57) on April 17, 2007. [History, Amendments & Comments]

The vote was 51 in favor, 57 opposed, and 2 not voting
(House Roll Call 95 at House Journal 35)

Print-friendly version

[Comment on this vote | View others' comments]

Line

Vote
Support Support
Oppose Oppose
Not Voting Not Voting
 Undecided
Legislators (Democrat)
1991%
98298%
1000%
58 total votes
Legislators (Republican)
96496%
1000%
3973%
52 total votes

What do you think? Support Oppose Undecided (logon required)

Line

The following legislators supported the substitute:

Acciavatti (R) Agema (R) Amos (R) Ball (R) Booher (R) Brandenburg (R)
Calley (R) Casperson (R) Caswell (R) Caul (R) DeRoche (R) Elsenheimer (R)
Gaffney (R) Green (R) Hansen (R) Hildenbrand (R) Hoogendyk (R) Hopgood (D)
Horn (R) Huizenga (R) Hune (R) Jones, Rick (R) Knollenberg (R) LaJoy (R)
Law, David (R) Marleau (R) Meekhof (R) Meltzer (R) Moolenaar (R) Moore (R)
Moss (R) Nitz (R) Nofs (R) Opsommer (R) Palmer (R) Palsrok (R)
Pastor (R) Pavlov (R) Pearce (R) Proos (R) Robertson (R) Rocca (R)
Schuitmaker (R) Shaffer (R) Sheen (R) Stahl (R) Stakoe (R) Steil (R)
Walker (R) Ward (R) Wenke (R)    

The following legislators opposed the substitute:

Accavitti (D) Angerer (D) Bauer (D) Bennett (D) Bieda (D) Brown (D)
Byrnes (D) Byrum (D) Cheeks (D) Clack (D) Clemente (D) Condino (D)
Constan (D) Corriveau (D) Coulouris (D) Cushingberry (D) Dean (D) Dillon (D)
Donigan (D) Ebli (D) Espinoza (D) Farrah (D) Gillard (D) Gonzales (D)
Griffin (D) Hammel (D) Hammon (D) Hood (D) Jackson (D) Johnson (D)
Jones, Robert (D) Lahti (D) Law, Kathleen (D) LeBlanc (D) Leland (D) Lemmons (D)
Lindberg (D) Mayes (D) McDowell (D) Meadows (D) Meisner (D) Melton (D)
Miller (D) Polidori (D) Sak (D) Scott (D) Sheltrown (D) Simpson (D)
Smith, Alma (D) Smith, Virgil (D) Spade (D) Tobocman (D) Vagnozzi (D) Valentine (D)
Warren (D) Wojno (D) Young (D)    

The following legislators did not vote on the substitute:

Emmons (R) Garfield (R)

Line

Most Recent Comments

1) 2007 House Bill 4375 (Revise commercial rental property assessment occupancy formula ) [by admin on January 1, 2001]
Introduced in the House on March 1, 2007, to eliminate a cap on the maximum amount that tax assessors can raise the assessment of rental property due to a higher occupancy rate, if the assessment had been previously lowered as a result of a lower occupancy rate. A 2002 Supreme Court ruling (WPW vs. Troy) held that raising these assessments faster than inflation violates the Constitutional tax cap put in place by Proposal A in 1994, which limits assessment increases to five percent or the rate of inflation, whichever is less. This bill exempts commercial rental property from the regular property tax law, and instead subject it to a new property tax law which taxes this property at the same rate as the current law. Note: The effect of the bills in some sense would be retroactive, requiring property owners to pay higher taxes in the future to compensate governments for past tax savings under the WPW ruling

The vote was 59 in favor, 49 opposed and 2 not voting

(House Roll Call 96 at House Journal 35)

Click here to view bill details.
Reply

Line


View Full Conversation