Legislation watch
Mackinac Center for Public Policy
Capitol Building

2010 House Bill 6534: Ban large lottery prizes for welfare, food stamp & Medicaid recipients

facebook  twitter    Comments on this legislation    Post new comment    Text and Analysis    Add to Watch List 
  Previous   Next 

Comments

1) Re: 2010 House Bill 6534 (Ban large lottery prizes for welfare, food stamp & Medicaid recipients )  by smile on December 2, 2010 

 


I hope everyone opposes this, please.  LOTTO IS LEGAL IN AMERICA.  Next MEDICARE people (Insurance for those over 65)won't be able to buy lottery because they get GOVERNMENT INSURANCE.  I do not like this bill.  Next it will be said what you can and cannot buy, they could extend this to many other things that are felt government recipients should and shouldn't be buying, paying for kids to be in sports or art activities, etc.  Maybe next you will not be able to buy a computer because you could use it for playing games and not going to work.  I think this is a bill of discrimination/communism.  If you win, you would be obviously kicked off of welfare anyway and save taxpayers and also probably give back or should feel compelled to give back.  I know I would.   What about our schools who benefit from the ticket sales.  It is a vicious cycle of bad.  Please say no.  Thank you to all the pound the congress people with SAY NO TO BILL 6534!

Line

2) Re: 2010 House Bill 6534 (Ban large lottery prizes for welfare, food stamp & Medicaid recipients )  by coyotemike on October 27, 2010 

This bill is so anti-freedom!!!!! I think if you want to make any kind of law with lotto and welfare assisted people, make them pay back the assistance they received. I also don't like the idea that welfare receivers are using our tax money to gamble. But even if they did try to teach people how to save and what-not it wouldn't do any good. People that want to gamble are going to gamble. If we as a society are going to give our poor people money as a gift, then we can't tell them what to do with it. I just have a problem with the whole idea of the government telling people what they can and can't spend money on.


Line

3) Re: 2010 House Bill 6534 (Ban large lottery prizes for welfare, food stamp & Medicaid recipients )  by lovefreedom on October 23, 2010 

This is another example of our elected representatives having nothing better to do than worry about what people might be doing with their money. Someone else posted that the lottery, in all its forms, is a "poor man's tax" which is absolutely true. But how is it right to allow people on any sort of public assistance to PLAY but then not allow them to COLLECT?


Here's an idea: How about if this representative, and his colleagues, spend time figuring out how to create jobs and ways to get people OFF the public dole, and then we would not have to worry about how those people spend their money?


Line

View pre-2013 Comments.
Your new comments should be made in the box below.