Legislation watch
Mackinac Center for Public Policy
Capitol Building

2007 House Bill 5549: Impose “renewable energy” mandates on utilities
  1. Introduced by Rep. David Palsrok (R) on December 6, 2007, to mandate that electric utilities acquire a certain amount of their power from “renewable” sources, with the specifics to be determined by the Public Service Commission according to a formula contained in the bill. The commission would have discretion to grant exemptions. "Renewable energy" is defined as that generated by biomass, geothermal, solar, wind, hydroelectric, industrial cogeneration, and gas captured from the decomposition of waste. Nuclear power is not included in the definition, but is not explicitly excluded as in other similar bills.
    • Referred to the House Energy and Technology Committee on December 6, 2007.
      • Reported in the House on January 24, 2008, with the recommendation that the substitute (H-1) be adopted and that the bill then pass.
    • Substitute offered in the House on April 17, 2008, to replace the previous version of the bill with one that makes substantive revisions based on months of lobbying and negotiations. This version was subsequently superseded by another substitute with more changes. The substitute failed by voice vote in the House on April 17, 2008.
    • Substitute offered by Rep. David Palsrok (R) on April 17, 2008, to replace the previous version of the bill with one that makes substantive revisions based on months of lobbying and negotiations. See House-passed version for details. The substitute passed by voice vote in the House on April 17, 2008.
    • Amendment offered by Rep. Kevin Green (R) on April 17, 2008, to clarify a technical provision in the bill so the language of the amended law is internally consistent. The amendment passed by voice vote in the House on April 17, 2008.
    • Amendment offered by Rep. Bill Huizenga (R) on April 17, 2008, to suspend the renewable energy mandates if an annual report the Public Service Commission would be required to prepare shows that this regime does not result in specified levels of "cumulative net job creation" in the state, meaning more "renewable energy" jobs are created than jobs are lost in other sectors of the economy because of the higher electricity prices the proposed law would generate.
      • Withdrawn in the House on April 17, 2008.
  2. Passed 82 to 21 in the House on April 17, 2008, to mandate that Michigan electric utilities acquire 4 percent of their power from "renewable" sources by the end of 2012, and 10 percent by the end of 2015. The mandate would be reduced to the extent it increased residential rates by more than $3 per month, and on commercial customers from $15.83 to $187.50 per month. Utilities could meet the mandate by producing or purchasing renewable energy, or purchasing "credits" from a firm that exceeded the mandate. The provisions creating this regime are divided between this and House Bill 5548.
    Who Voted "Yes" and Who Voted "No"

  3. Moved to reconsider by Rep. Steve Tobocman (D) on April 17, 2008, the vote by which the House passed the bill. The motion passed by voice vote in the House on April 17, 2008.
  4. Received in the House on April 17, 2008, to mandate that Michigan electric utilities acquire 4 percent of their power from "renewable" sources by the end of 2012, and 10 percent by the end of 2015. The mandate would be reduced to the extent it increased residential rates by more than $3 per month, and on commercial customers from $15.83 to $187.50 per month. Utilities could meet the mandate by producing or purchasing renewable energy, or purchasing "credits" from a firm that exceeded the mandate. The provisions creating this regime are divided between this and House Bill 5548. Passed 84 to 21 in the House on April 17, 2008.
    Who Voted "Yes" and Who Voted "No"

  5. Received in the Senate on April 22, 2008.
    • Referred to the Senate Energy Policy & Public Utilities Committee on April 22, 2008.
      • Reported in the Senate on June 17, 2008, with the recommendation that the substitute (S-1) be adopted and that the bill then pass.

Comments

Good job. Keep in mind one type of geothermal wastes TONS of water.  by Anonymous Citizen on June 20, 2008 
2007 House Bill 5549 (Impose “renewable energy” mandates on utilities ) (House Roll Call 300)

Passed in the House (84 to 21) on April 17, 2008. [History, Amendments & Comments]

The vote was 84 in favor, 21 opposed, and 5 not voting
(House Roll Call 300 at House Journal 35)



[Comment on this vote | View others' comments]



Vote
Support
Oppose
Not Voting
Undecided
Legislators (Democrat)
91%
0%
8%

58 total votes

Legislators (Republican)
59%
40%
0%

52 total votes

Voters
50%
50%
0%

2 total votes



What do you think? Support Oppose Undecided (logon required)




The following legislators supported 2007 House Bill 5549 (Impose “renewable energy” mandates on utilities ):

Accavitti (D) Angerer (D) Ball (R) Bauer (D) Bieda (D) Booher (R)
Brown (D) Byrnes (D) Byrum (D) Calley (R) Caswell (R) Caul (R)
Cheeks (D) Clack (D) Clemente (D) Condino (D) Constan (D) Corriveau (D)
Coulouris (D) Dean (D) Dillon (D) Donigan (D) Ebli (D) Farrah (D)
Gaffney (R) Gillard (D) Gonzales (D) Green (R) Griffin (D) Hammel (D)
Hammon (D) Hansen (R) Hildenbrand (R) Hood (D) Hopgood (D) Horn (R)
Hune (R) Jackson (D) Johnson (D) Jones, Rick (R) Jones, Robert (D) Knollenberg (R)
Lahti (D) LaJoy (R) Law, David (R) Law, Kathleen (D) LeBlanc (D) Leland (D)
Lemmons (D) Lindberg (D) Marleau (R) Mayes (D) Meadows (D) Meisner (D)
Melton (D) Meltzer (R) Miller (D) Moore (R) Moss (R) Nofs (R)
Opsommer (R) Palsrok (R) Pastor (R) Pearce (R) Polidori (D) Proos (R)
Rocca (R) Sak (D) Schuitmaker (R) Shaffer (R) Sheltrown (D) Simpson (D)
Smith, Alma (D) Smith, Virgil (D) Spade (D) Tobocman (D) Vagnozzi (D) Valentine (D)
Walker (R) Ward (R) Warren (D) Wenke (R) Wojno (D) Young (D)

The following legislators opposed 2007 House Bill 5549 (Impose “renewable energy” mandates on utilities ):

Acciavatti (R) Agema (R) Amos (R) Brandenburg (R) Casperson (R) DeRoche (R)
Elsenheimer (R) Emmons (R) Garfield (R) Hoogendyk (R) Huizenga (R) Meekhof (R)
Moolenaar (R) Nitz (R) Palmer (R) Pavlov (R) Robertson (R) Sheen (R)
Stahl (R) Stakoe (R) Steil (R)

The following legislators did not vote on 2007 House Bill 5549 (Impose “renewable energy” mandates on utilities ):

Bennett (D) Cushingberry (D) Espinoza (D) McDowell (D) Scott (D)


"no vote explanation"  by Admin003 on April 20, 2008 
Rep. Nitz, having reserved the right to explain his protest against the passage of the bill, made the following statement:

“Mr. Speaker and members of the House:

I voted against this bill because it mandates that there must be a certain amount of ‘green energy’ produced, and I am against mandating anything. If it is cost effective the market would be providing green energy.”


"journal statement"  by Admin003 on April 20, 2008 
Rep. McDowell, under Rule 31, made the following statement:

“Mr. Speaker and members of the House:

I did not vote on Roll Call No. 300 because of a possible conflict of interest.”


View pre-2013 Comments.
Your new comments should be made in the box below.