Legislation watch
Mackinac Center for Public Policy
Capitol Building

2005 Senate Bill 453: Establish state earned income tax credit

Public Act 372 of 2006

facebook  twitter    Comments on this legislation    Post new comment    Text and Analysis    Add to Watch List 
  Previous   Next 

Most Recent Comments

1) Re: 2005 Senate Bill 453 (Establish state earned income tax credit )  by catalinoss on June 9, 2011 

The Senate must explain why the relation was used in this way. Is there another way to produce the same effects ? I don't believe it ! hotel ieftin bucuresti


Reply

Line

2) Rep. Drolet's "no vote explanation"  by Admin003 on September 7, 2006 
Rep. Drolet, having reserved the right to explain his protest against the passage of the bill, made the following statement:

"Mr. Speaker and members of the House:

I am always supportive of tax cuts, and any measure that reduces the amount of money that government takes from individuals. However, this bill is not primarily a tax cut--it is a redistribution of taxpayer money.

This 'credit' does more than merely cut taxes payed by some citizens. Instead it actually PAYS some citizens to not pay taxes. Over 88% of those eligible for this credit get refunds in excess of what they actually payed in taxes. In other words, the state is taking money from some citizens and paying it out to other citizens in cash.

Economist Milton Friedman, and President Ronald Reagan supported tax credits such as this as a replacement for the current, and ineffective welfare programs we have in place, NOT in addition to them. If this credit were being introduced for this purpose, to give cash directly to those in need in place of the millions spent on welfare programs, I would be supportive. However, as it stands this bill is merely a redistribution of taxpayer money by the state reminiscent of the policies of socialist governments of the past.

I will, and have always supported any tax cut for the citizens of Michigan. I cannot, and will not support any effort to take money from one taxpayer and pay it out to another. That is why I am voting 'no' on SB 453."

Reply

Line

3) The Reason That  by Anonymous Citizen on September 6, 2006 
this state is going down the tubes is because there is not one conservative, common sense person left in lansing. Maybe the water is bad and causes them to want to give away money to get elected. Maybe the canadian governor spiked the punch. If you keep giving money away pretty soon there will be no one left working, then what will you geniuses do? Do whats right, Stop the insanity.
Reply

Line


View Full Conversation