Legislation watch
Mackinac Center for Public Policy
Capitol Building

2002 House Bill 5881

Public Act 521 of 2002

[Comments on this legislation] [Post new comment] [Text and Analysis] [Add to Watch List]
[Previous] [Next]

Most Recent Comments

1) Timothy Walsh [by Anonymous Citizen on August 5, 2002]
I would just like you to know that neither you nor anyone else that supported an increase in taxes, especially cigarette taxes will not receive another penney in support nor a vote from myself or my family.
Reply

Line

2) CIGARETTE TAX INCREASE [by Anonymous Citizen on July 16, 2002]
RE: CIG TAX INCREASE--REPLUBLICANS LOVE TAXES JUST AS MUCH AS DEMS!!


SHAME ON EVERY REPUBLICAN ..SHAME ON EVERY DEMOCRAT , WHO ONCE AGAIN FLEW THE FLAG OF RIGHTOUSNESS WHILE STICKING IT TO THE POOR AND LOWER MIDDLE CLASS IN THE STATE!

"HELPING PEOPLE QUIT SMOKING".."SAVING MONEY ON SMOKING RELATED HEALTH PROBLEMS". B.S.!!!! PLEASE DON'T INSULT OUR INTELLIGENCE WITH THAT OLD STRAW MAN.

THIS IS A NO BRAINER. " WE DID SUCH A LOUSY JOB OF TAKING CARE OF THE STATE'S FINANCING, SO LET'S MAKE IT RIGHT BY STICKING IT TO THE HELPLESS AND DEFENCELESS"! THE POOR AND LOWER CLASS WHO MAKE UP THE BULK OF SMOKERS, CANNOT FIGHT BACK.

CAN YOU IMAGINE ANY ONE OF THOSE "BRAVE" LEGISLATORS WHO VOTED FOR THIS MESS PROPOSING A TAX ON FAT PRODUCTS ..CHEESEBURGERS, FRIES, MALTS, ICE CREAM, ETC..BECAUSE OBESITY KILLS? HA HA. CAN YOU JUST SEE THEM FIGHTING ALL THOSE MONEY LADEN GROUPS!

OR CAN YOU IN YOUR WILDEST DRUNKEN STATE CONCEIVE OF THEM PROPOSING TO TAX GOLF COURSES? HIGH PRICED RESTAURANTS? CABIN CRUISERS? LUXURY AUTOS? HOTEL ROOMS OVER $90 A NIGHT?

WELL..YOU GET THE IDEA. NEVER HAVE, NEVER WILL.

NO GUTS.

WELL, AT LEAST WE'RE MAKING INDIANA AND OHIO HAPPY, NOT TO SPEAK OF THE SMUGGLERS WHO ARE SALAVATING FOR THE WONDERFUL OPPORTUNITIES BEGINING AUG 1.

IF YOU DO SMOKE, GET TOGETHER AND FORM A CLUB. ONCE EVERY TWO MONTHS, FINANCE A VAN RUN TO INDIANA TO BRING BACK CIGS FOR MEMBERS.

BETTER YET, IF YOU KNOW SOMEONE WHO'S IN THE MILITARY OR A RETIRED MILITARY.. GET THEM TO SEND YOU CHEAP COMMISARY CIGS.

BY THE WAY, I DON'T SMOKE. IT JUST BUGS THE HELL OUT OF ME TO SEE THE DEFENCELESS GET LANCED AGAIN BY OUR SO CALLED REPS IN LANSING.

BY THE WAY, IF YOU SEE ENGLER & HIS ILK OR ANYONE ELSE WHO VOTED FOR THIS TRAVESTY RUNNING FOR ANOTHER OFFICE (AND YOU WILL) VOTE THEM OUT...BECAUSE THEY WILL TAX THE DAYLIGHTS OUT OF YOU.

GO JENIFER GO! WE NEED YOU NOW!
Reply

Line

3) Rep. Spade's "No vote explanation" [by Admin003 on June 20, 2002]
Rep. Spade, having reserved the right to explain his nay vote, made the following statement:
“Mr. Speaker and members of the House:
I voted no on HB 5881 because it is irresponsible to pass a two-year K-12 budget when the state continues to
experience declining revenues. The language in the bill linking school aid for 2003-04 to approval of a cigarette tax
increase inappropriately attempts to force one segment of the state’s population to shoulder an inordinate proportion
of the expense. Furthermore, history has shown that this legislature cannot entirely keep its promises to schools and
frequently makes negative budget adjustments to them. Passage of this bill would have given no guarantee to schools
that the funding would be forthcoming. And the next legislature would be under no obligation to adhere to this budget’s
provisions.”
Reply

Line


View Full Conversation